Friday, January 16, 2009

Dear JLI -

In our JLI class, we talked a lot about leadership and our roles as leaders. A friend of mine told me about this situation she recently encountered and didn't know how to handle it.

She works for an organization that deals with helping citizens in 3rd world countries get a leg up. Her role specifically is to take the donors to the organization to visit the sites where their funds are going. On one such trip, the group was visiting an NGO that supports and empowers sex-workers by giving them skills in English language, computer training and other education on safe sex and labor rights. Of course, this is a difficult situation for us as Americans to deal with because of our clear sense of moral certitude.

Upon bringing the group of donors to meet these sex-workers, one of the donors on the trip was extremely vocal and judgemental about the NGO's work and their approach. The donor felt that the NGO should have been working to rehabilitate sex workers and that the efforts to make their jobs safe were misguided and morally wrong. The donor made her opinions very public to the entire group. She and others began to take pictures and disrespect an earlier request to be patient and sensitive with these women and specifically not take photographs.

The situation was particularly challenging because of the dynamic between my friend's aid organization and the community, and between her as a staff member and the donors. The problematic donor had given a substantial gift to the organization, and she feard insulting her, but at the same time feared creating a strained relationship between her organizaation and the people they are committed to helping.

What should she have done in the situation?

1 comments:

Richard Dine said...

Does this NGO help people in the US or abroad? Are these sex workers working somewhere where the practice is legal, or is this illegal? If abroad and illegal, I wonder if Nicholas Kristoff would respond to a request for his opinion. He has been quite articulate on the problems these women face and his opinion might carry weight with your donor.
Israel has also taken a lead in trying to stop sex traffic, and I know someone in the Justice Ministry there who is involved, who might also have a perspective.
If the issue is that NGO is helping workers where the practice is legal, I admit to some sympathy to the donor. I would think an organization should be helping these sex workers find a better profession.